Talk:Advice: Caning
(Reply) |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
I see that in June 2006, the [[Cane]] topic was moved to this topic, [[Advice: Caning]]. A lot of the text here doesn't seem to be about Advice but about canes or caning. Does anyone mind if I have a go at splitting this text out? I also think [[Caning]] should redirect to [[Birching]] rather than [[Cane]] - any comments? --[[User:Interesdom|Interesdom]] 17:14, 8 December 2007 (UTC) | I see that in June 2006, the [[Cane]] topic was moved to this topic, [[Advice: Caning]]. A lot of the text here doesn't seem to be about Advice but about canes or caning. Does anyone mind if I have a go at splitting this text out? I also think [[Caning]] should redirect to [[Birching]] rather than [[Cane]] - any comments? --[[User:Interesdom|Interesdom]] 17:14, 8 December 2007 (UTC) | ||
: Certainly go ahead and split it out. Is caning synonymous with birching? You can hit people with a wide variety of objects, e.g. paddle, cane, crop, whip, switch, belt or the hand. Let's link them all from [[Corporal punishment]].--[[User:Taxwoman|Taxwoman]] 15:01, 9 December 2007 (UTC) | : Certainly go ahead and split it out. Is caning synonymous with birching? You can hit people with a wide variety of objects, e.g. paddle, cane, crop, whip, switch, belt or the hand. Let's link them all from [[Corporal punishment]].--[[User:Taxwoman|Taxwoman]] 15:01, 9 December 2007 (UTC) | ||
| + | |||
| + | The book ''A Guide to the Correction of Young Gentlemen: the successful administration of physical discipline to males - by females'' was written by the late '''Jacqueline Ophir''' in the 1980’s and published by the Alice Kerr-Sutherland Society (AKS). That it was written by the Alice Kerr-Sutherland in 1924 but before it could be published all known copies were seized by England's Vice Squad and, after a sensational trial, burned - by order of the judge (except one) is a myth! | ||
Revision as of 10:01, 5 January 2008
I see that in June 2006, the Cane topic was moved to this topic, Advice: Caning. A lot of the text here doesn't seem to be about Advice but about canes or caning. Does anyone mind if I have a go at splitting this text out? I also think Caning should redirect to Birching rather than Cane - any comments? --Interesdom 17:14, 8 December 2007 (UTC)
- Certainly go ahead and split it out. Is caning synonymous with birching? You can hit people with a wide variety of objects, e.g. paddle, cane, crop, whip, switch, belt or the hand. Let's link them all from Corporal punishment.--Taxwoman 15:01, 9 December 2007 (UTC)
The book A Guide to the Correction of Young Gentlemen: the successful administration of physical discipline to males - by females was written by the late Jacqueline Ophir in the 1980’s and published by the Alice Kerr-Sutherland Society (AKS). That it was written by the Alice Kerr-Sutherland in 1924 but before it could be published all known copies were seized by England's Vice Squad and, after a sensational trial, burned - by order of the judge (except one) is a myth!
